What To Do When Your Poem Is Accepted
This article is for: Beginning and Intermediate Poets
The email you've been waiting for just arrived. Now what?
Almost everything written about getting answers back from journal and magazines about your poems is about rejection—how to handle it, how to keep going, how not to take it personally. I've written about that myself, more than once!
But nobody seems to write the other article: the one about what happens when the answer is “Yes.”
And that's a shame, because an acceptance brings its own small flurry of things to do—some of them urgent, one of them genuinely important—and if you've never had one before, it's not at all obvious what they are.
So: congratulations. Your poem has been accepted. Here's exactly what to do next.
Improve your poetry fast!
Get your free eBook with my top poetry tips:
8 Steps To Better Poems
First: enjoy it
I mean this seriously, as step one!
Poets are bad at this. We spend months absorbing rejections, and then when something finally lands we allow ourselves about four seconds of pleasure before moving straight on to "Well, it's only a small journal," or "They probably had a weak batch this time."
Don't do that. An editor read your poem among many others and chose yours. Sit with that for an evening. Tell someone. The whole point of sending work out is that sometimes it comes back a yes—so let the yes actually land!
But there are practical things you need to do, so let’s turn to those.
Next: Reply promptly and simply
Send a short, warm reply confirming that the poem is still available and that you're delighted.
That's all it needs to be—two or three sentences. Thank them, confirm, and say you look forward to working with them.
Don't overthink this any more than you overthought your cover letter. You're not auditioning again; you've already got the part. A brief, friendly, professional note is exactly right.
If the editor has asked you for anything specific—a bio, a preferred spelling of your name, a form to fill in—answer all of it in that same reply. Editors are juggling dozens of contributors. Being the poet who answers everything the first time is a quiet kindness that gets remembered.
Then—urgently—withdraw the poem from everywhere else
Here's the part that actually matters, and the part new poets most often get wrong.
If you've sent that poem to other journals as a simultaneous submission—which is normal and sensible—you must now tell those other journals that it's no longer available. Immediately. Not at the weekend. Not when you next sit down at your desk. Right now!
You might think there’s no hurry, but you’d be surprised how often it happens that another editor says Yes to your poem very soon after the first one. And if you have to say, Sorry, this poem is taken, you are likely to annoy that editor quite a lot.
I learned this the hard way.
Some years ago, I had a poem accepted by a journal one evening. Lovely news, and I was thrilled. It was late, I was tired, and I thought: I'll withdraw it from everywhere else first thing in the morning. Perfectly reasonable, yes?
In the morning, there was another email waiting. A press had accepted the very same poem for an anthology.
So I had to write back and grovel—a long, mortified, apologetic email explaining that the poem was no longer available. I never received a reply. I've submitted to that press again since. I've never been accepted again. I don't know that the two things are connected, and I'll never know. But I've thought about it a lot.
The other editor hadn't just read my poem—she'd chosen it. She'd been assembling an anthology, curating a group of poems that would sit together and speak to each other. She'd probably spent a long time on that. She may well have known exactly where in the book she wanted to put my poem. And then she'd sent me an email, excited, believing she was giving me wonderful news.
I upset all of that, and I imagine I left a sour taste. I wouldn’t blame her if she never takes another poem of mine.
So the lesson is: move fast. Withdraw the moment you're accepted, even when it's late, even when you're tired.
How to withdraw the poem
Different journals handle this differently, so check each journal’s Submissions page for their instructions.
Some want you to email them, some ask you to send them a message in Submittable.
But if your accepted poem was part of a packet, don’t withdraw your whole submission. The other poems in your packet are still available, so you want all those other editors to still consider them for publication!
Instead, withdraw just the accepted poem, with a message something like this:
Dear Editors,
I need to withdraw my poem “Running from Polar Bears” from my May 15 submission to you, as it has been accepted by Errant Penguin magazine. The remaining poems in my submission are still available.
Thank you,
[Your Name]
Keep it brief and polite, and don't apologize (unless you’ve done what I did!)—withdrawing is a normal part of the process, and editors deal with it constantly.
Between acceptance and publication
Once the admin is done, things usually go quiet for a while. Here's roughly what to expect.
1. Sometimes the editor asks for changes. Occasionally an acceptance arrives with a suggestion attached—cut the last stanza, lose that adjective, reconsider the title. Sometimes the Yes even depends on it. This is not a trap, and it isn't a sign they've gone off the poem. It means an editor has read your work closely enough to have thoughts about it, which is rarer and more valuable than it feels in the moment.
The key thing to know is that it's a conversation, not an order. You're allowed to agree, to agree partly, or to explain—politely—why you'd rather keep something as it is. A good editor will respect a considered answer. This is a big enough subject that I'll give it an article of its own soon, but for now: read the suggestion twice, sleep on it, and reply as a collaborator rather than a defendant.
2. Proofs. Many journals will send you a proof of your poem before publication. Read it carefully—and read it as a proofreader, not as a poet. You're checking that they've reproduced your poem accurately: line breaks, spacing, stanza breaks, punctuation, capitalization. Poems are unusually vulnerable to formatting accidents, and a lost line break can genuinely change the poem.
What proofs are not is an invitation to revise. Resist the urge to improve the poem now. The editor accepted the poem you sent; quietly rewriting it at proof stage is bad form. Fix errors, not opinions—unless the editor has actually invited a change, which is the different situation I described above.
3. Timelines. Publication can be months away, sometimes a year. This is normal. Don't chase—but if a promised date passes with no word, a polite check-in after a reasonable interval is entirely fair.
4. Payment and contributor copies. Poetry pays badly or not at all, and that's not a reflection on you or the journal. Many journals pay in contributor copies—one or two copies of the issue you're in. Some pay a small fee. Some pay nothing. Whatever they've promised, it typically arrives around publication rather than acceptance.
When it's published
Buy the issue, or at least read it. You're now part of a conversation—the other poems in that issue are your company. Reading them is both interesting and the decent thing to do.
Share the news, but share it generously. By all means announce it. The trick is to point at the journal, not just at yourself: name the publication, link to it, mention another poem in the issue you admired. It's more graceful, and it supports the people who supported you.
And thank the editor once, briefly, when it appears. They almost never hear from anyone after publication day.
One more thing: your poem is now "published"
This has practical consequences you'll want to remember.
That poem generally can't be submitted to journals or contests as new work anymore. Most outlets want previously unpublished poems, and a published poem is out of the running. (This is exactly the eligibility trap I wrote about in how to choose which poems to submit—it just now applies to you in a much happier way.)
Two useful exceptions to know about:
Reprints. Some journals and anthologies do accept previously published work, as long as you tell them where it appeared first. Check the guidelines.
Collections. A poem published in a journal is still absolutely eligible for your own future pamphlet or book. In fact, journal publications are how most collections get built—and a list of them strengthens a manuscript submission considerably.
So update your bio. You now have a publication credit, and it belongs in that short third-person paragraph you keep for cover letters. Add it while you remember.
A quick note on contests
Most of the above applies to a competition win or placing too, with a few differences: prizes usually come with publication attached, so the same "now it's published" rules kick in; there may be prize money, a reading, or publicity; and organizers often want a photo and a longer bio at short notice.
The withdrawal point applies just as much—if a poem wins something, get it out of every other queue immediately.
Next Steps
These are the things to do the moment a poem of yours is accepted—so bookmark this and come back to it when that email arrives.
Reply today. A short, warm confirmation. Answer every question the editor asked, in that one email.
Withdraw the poem everywhere else, right now. Not tomorrow. Use each journal's stated method. If only one poem from a batch was taken, withdraw that poem only and leave the others in.
Make a simple submissions record, if you don't already keep one—poem title, where sent, date, outcome. This is what makes fast withdrawal possible, because you'll know instantly where else a poem is sitting. A spreadsheet is plenty.
Update your bio with the new credit, and move the poem out of your "available to submit" pile.
Then celebrate properly—and get back to writing the next one.
Congratulations again. Someone chose your poem. That's worth something, and it means the work is working.
